The Midterm Conversation We’re Avoiding

We’re building a group chat.

By Jon Favreau, Host, Pod Save America & Offline

  • Democracy
  • Voting

Note: This blog was originally posted on Crooked Media’s substack. You can read the original post here.

“How are you feeling about the election?” is the question I get from pretty much everyone I talk to this time of year. People who don’t know me as well usually follow up with some version of “sorry, you must get tired of talking about this.”

But I don’t! I honestly love talking about politics with anyone, anytime for the same reason I do it professionally: I’m a sicko.

I’ll be honest, though: outside of work, I’m less comfortable having conversations with people about their politics, especially if they differ from mine. Some of that is a congenital aversion to conflict that I promise I’m working on. But I feel like these conversations have become even harder. And I’m not the only one.

Fifty-six percent of Americans have stopped discussing political news with someone because of something that person said, according to Pew. That’s up from 45% in 2024.

Look, I get it. Speculating with someone about what other voters will do on Tuesday is easier than asking what they’re gonna do and why – especially if they give you an opinion you disagree with, or tell you they aren’t convinced voting is even worth it. At which point you might change the subject because you’d rather not pick a fight or just don’t know what to say next.

The internet and social media have given us countless ways to express our opinions while avoiding conversations that ask more of us. We can post our takes (guilty), fight with strangers (guilty), share things we agree with and dunk on things we don’t (guilty and guilty). And we can do it all without ever having to really understand someone else’s frustration, or respond to criticism we find unfair, or actually try to persuade people who might need more than a link you posted with an all-caps THIS and multiple clap emojis.

Campaigns have a related problem: they’ve gotten much better at figuring out which voters they want to reach, but much worse at actually reaching them.

In 2024, Democrats made 300 million attempts to contact voters by phone. They got through just 3% of the time. And honestly, my first reaction was: who are those 3%? I barely answer calls from people I know. Same with texts and emails. That’s why we have spam filters and Ring cameras. We’ve spent years developing increasingly sophisticated ways to avoid strangers who want something from us – while campaigns have spent that time developing increasingly sophisticated ways to become the strangers we avoid.

But what if the answer isn’t finding a better way for strangers to reach us?

When Pete Buttigieg ran for president, volunteers were asked to write down the names of people they knew on a piece of paper. Organizers helped them think through how to approach each person, then counted actual conversations instead of just calls made.

The person who led that effort is Greta Carnes, who now works with us at Vote Save America. After the 2024 election, she helped put together a groundbreaking report urging campaigns to invest much more in these conversations. Greta cites research suggesting that this approach, known as relational organizing, can be two and a half times as effective as outreach from strangers.

But if we take this to mean treating everyone we know as another voter contact, we’re missing the point. People don’t want their friends texting them campaign talking points any more than they want another automated text begging for money.

What makes a conversation with someone you know different isn’t just that they’re more likely to listen to you. It’s that you’re more likely to listen to them. Pew also found that 59% of people who discuss the news say those conversations at least sometimes change their own opinions.
Let’s say a friend tells you they aren’t voting because both parties suck. You could lecture them about their civic and moral obligations. You could explain each candidate’s policy agenda and see how long it takes them to pay attention to literally anything else.

Or you could ask what makes them feel that way. And then actually listen.

You might change their mind about voting, you might not. But you’ll probably learn something new about how they came to believe what they believe. Maybe a candidate they volunteered for let them down once they got the job. Maybe they spent months trying to get someone in government to help them with a problem that made their life hell. Maybe you’re both just seeing completely different videos and information in your feeds. You might think they’re drawing the wrong conclusions from those experiences. But even if you don’t change their mind in that first conversation, understanding where they’re coming from gives you a better chance of getting through to them the next time you talk. And maybe they’ll be a little more willing to hear you out, too.

I think one reason politics gets so exhausting is how much of it we experience as spectators. I mean, I am just taking content to the face all day: a fire hose of clips and polls and takes and discourse. Sometimes it feels like I’m trying to inhale as much information as possible out of a mistaken belief that having just a little bit more will provide some kind of certainty about what’s going to happen next.

But it won’t. It can’t. Knowing more about politics doesn’t necessarily make us feel any more capable of changing it. For that, you need to actually do politics with other people. And people can be annoying – even and maybe especially people you know. But politics is fundamentally about figuring out how to accomplish things with people who don’t always see the world the way we do. If we’re only willing to talk to people who agree with us, we’re not building a movement. We’re building a group chat.

No one needs to convert all their contacts into Democratic voters by Tuesday. There are plenty of other ways to make a difference before the polls close. Help a friend navigate their ballot or figure out where to vote. Offer a ride. Make a plan to go together. And if you’ve got time to volunteer, Vote Save America can help you find doors to knock and voters to call – including people outside your own circles, who campaigns still need to reach.

But over the next few days, try asking someone in your life how they’re feeling about the election. Not just who they think will win, but what they’d actually like to see change, and why. And if their answer makes you want to change the subject, try asking one more question instead.

That’s what I’m going to try to do.


Ready to help EVERYONE you know go vote?

We’ve got everything you need to get started. Use our tools to map your networks in competitive districts, get information about candidates running in your state, and more!

Get Your People to the Polls